Phillies hint at unusual position shift that could reshape Bryce Harper’s long-term role
The Philadelphia Phillies appear to be exploring a surprising defensive adjustmentone that could ultimately impact Bryce Harper’s future with the team.
Harper’s 2026 campaign hasn’t begun the way a two time MVP would hope. Through the first five games, he’s slashing just .100/.182/.100, and early defensive metrics haven’t been kind either, assigning him -2 Defensive Runs Saved at first base.
Given that, it’s understandable the Phillies are testing alternatives at the position. Strong first base defense can elevate the entire infield, and Harper’s performance there has dipped significantly since his standout showing in 2024.
What is unexpected, however, is who the Phillies are turning to for reps.
Kyle Schwarber taking first-base work raises eyebrows
Fans with good memories will recall that this experiment isn’t entirely new—the Phillies gave Kyle Schwarber some first-base looks during last year’s spring training as well.
He hasn’t played first in a regular-season game since 2021 with the Boston Red Sox, and he hasn’t manned the position for any other club. His previous attempt didn’t go especially well either, as he posted -3 DRS in only 75 innings. Still, Schwarber’s elite power has always been strong enough to overshadow any defensive shortcomings.
Planning for contingencies is reasonable, but Harper’s slow start isn’t yet a crisis. His revamped approach at the plate should help his numbers normalize as the season unfolds.
And even if the Phillies did pursue a position change, it’s not as if it would automatically jump-start Harper’s production. Though he’s no longer the offensive force he once was in right field, his career OPS at first base (.873) and at designated hitter (.883) are nearly identical.
Schwarber shows a similar trend: he thrives when focusing solely on hitting. As a DH, he owns an .875 career OPS. When playing any defensive position, that number drops to .837.
With both stars earning a combined $55 million annually over the next five years, the Phillies need to be cautious. These two remain foundational hitters, and any significant defensive shake-up should be considered only when absolutely necessary.
For now, the team would be wise to allow both veterans time to settle in before making a move that could disrupt what has worked well in the past.
